Pinocchio’s Pizza

Reviews

• Cora B.

  star star star star_border star_border 5 October 2026

  Pretty good pizza.... until you get food poisoning. They have been a favorite place to go for my family for quite some time now, but recently my mother got horrible food poisoning, and when she called to tell them that, they offered her more pizza (?!? As if that's what she wanted?!?!) She also told the lady on the phone that she saw somebody handling tomatoes... WITH NO GLOVES!!! The woman told her that they aren't required to (which is bs because I've recently taken a food handlers test and passed and you are required to wear gloves and keep your hands clean.) I'm not trying to take down a decent business, I'm just letting everybody know that they should watch what they order. I hope that sometime soon they fix their cleanliness problem because they do make pretty good pizzas. If you're somebody who likes a good crunchy crust, maybe try it out.

• Hannah L.

  star star star star star 30 September 2026

  Have always loved Pinocchio's! It's my family's favorite pizza place and we stop there every time we visit Cottage Grove.

• Vicky C.

  star star star_border star_border star_border 19 September 2026

  We passed by on the road and took a stab at it. I should have read the reviews first. The signage and parking was great and the name quite catchy.
  
  As we entered, we were greeted by a young lady that was nice and kind. The other two gentleman in the cooking area had no welcoming facial gestures whatsoever. Didn't seem like they were happy at all.
  
  We ordered three pizza and waited patiently. It came out looking good but it really didn't taste good. The crust seemed dry and too crispy and the toppings were cold. We asked for a side of marinara sauce and it came out fridge cold. OUCH!
  
  Paid over 50.00 for everything and I feel Pizza Hut or Dominos would  have been better. I'm sorry but I would not recommend this place to anyone.
  
  Staff might consider having happier and more inviting personalities.

• Jason R.

  star star star star star_border 15 September 2026

  This was a great stop for our road trip!   The individual pizza's are very reasonably priced.   Very fast service and a great selection.   I got an oyster pizza and my wife got the Taco pizza.   I can't give them 5star because I would like to see a better beer selection and have a choice of crusts.

• Lee E.

  star star star star star 13 September 2026

  I was talking to a buddy last week about how pizza was better, and how the quality of pizza has gone down over the years. We took a chance and ordered Pinocchio's , and we certainly were not disappointed. Perfect old style Pizza. Some people say it's expensive but, it's not expensive at all.  You get what you pay for, if you want cheapsa go to a big chain pizza place.